Leader in the 2026 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Intranet Packaged Solutions

Get the report

Why Productivity and Engagement Are Really the Same Problem

Our head of solutions consulting explains how IT and HR can work together to solve their biggest workforce challenges.

November 18 2026|3 mins read

Ali Moore

Head of Solutions Consulting at Workvivo

Hot take: the biggest problem in most organizations isn’t low engagement or low productivity. It’s that two different departments are solving the same problem and neither one knows it.

Why productivity and engagement are really the same problem

I’ve had the slightly unusual career path of working across roles in HR, internal comms, marketing, sales, CX, and people management, and now solutions engineering. And the one thing that’s followed me through every single role is this conversation:

“How do we get people to be more productive?” asked by the CIO.

“How do we get people to be more engaged?” asked by the CHRO.

The same meetings across different companies – the same problems being talked about for the same people – and yet two completely separate plans, two separate budgets, and two sets of dashboards that never once speak to each other.

And honestly? It doesn’t make sense.

The false divide

Somewhere along the way, we decided that engagement belongs to HR and productivity belongs to IT.

HR runs the annual survey. IT rolls out the collaboration tools. HR worries about sentiment. IT worries about adoption metrics. And the employee – the actual human at the center of all this – just wants to find the right document without spending half the morning searching for it.

McKinsey found that employees spend an average of 9.3 hours per week just searching for and gathering information. That’s more than a full working day, every week, gone. Not because people aren’t engaged. Not because the tools are bad. But because the systems they work in weren’t designed with their actual experience in mind.

Meanwhile, Gallup’s research consistently shows that higher engagement correlates with higher productivity, higher profitability, and stronger sales outcomes at the business-unit level.

So the idea that these are separate problems to be solved by separate teams with separate tools? It doesn’t hold up.

What I’ve seen up close

When I was in HR, we’d run the engagement survey, package up the results, and hand managers a report. Most of them didn’t know what to do with it. When I was in internal comms roles, I saw the same pattern. There could be a great content strategy, but no line of sight into whether people were actually finding what they needed when they needed it.

And now, working in solutions engineering, I sit in customer conversations every week where the CIO and CHRO are essentially describing the same pain from completely different ends of the organization.

The CIO says: “Our people can’t find anything. They waste hours. We need better search, better knowledge management.”

The CHRO says: “Our people feel disconnected. They don’t trust leadership communication. They want to be heard.”

They’re both right. And they’re both describing the same experience, just through different lenses.

One problem, one lens

The organizations I see making real progress are the ones that have stopped treating employee experience as an HR project and started treating it as an operational one. They’re connecting the dots between how people feel, how they find information, how they collaborate, and how all of that shows up in actual business performance; because all of it together is the employee experience.

An employee’s experience of work – from the search friction to feeling a sense of belonging – needs to be treated as a single challenge, not a divided one. And measuring it that way is better for companies who genuinely care about that employee’s experience.

Because when your people can’t find answers, it chips away at their engagement one “not found” message at a time. When employees disengage, productivity drops and instead of addressing the root cause, the pressure to perform increases. But pressure without purpose doesn’t move the needle. Productivity stays flat, engagement falls further, and the cycle tightens.

It’s the same loop. We just keep measuring it from different starting points and looking at the wrong root cause. It is like trying to fix a loud clanking noise in your car by changing a different tire every single weekend.

You started with the front left, then tried the back right, and now you’re inspecting the spare. The car is still making the exact same sound because you refuse to look under the hood and notice the engine is literally held together by a single zip tie.

Stop paying twice to solve half

Productivity and engagement were never two challenges. They were always one, and we’ve been paying twice to solve half of it.

Organizations that break down the wall between HR and IT, that align their metrics, their tools, and their strategies around a single employee experience, don’t just see better survey scores or faster search results.

They see lower attrition, stronger performance, and cultures where people actually want to show up.

The cost of keeping these challenges separate is measurable. So is the upside of finally treating them as one. The question isn’t whether your organization can afford to make that shift – it’s whether you can afford to keep pretending you don’t need to.

Seer CTA.png

 

Authors:

Ali Moore

Head of Solutions Consulting at Workvivo